While he initially came into the investigation as a neighbor and former lover of Diehl-Armstrong, his involvement went much deeper, making us wonder, who is Bill Rothstein? If youve seen Evil Genius: The True Story of America's Most Diabolical Bank Heist, you know that there are many players involved, and twist upon twist that make us wonder who was really responsible for the death of Brian Wells. [4] Michael Rothenstein was a talented printmaker. News trucks and cameramen rushed to the scene. artist Augustus John and Rothenstein's wife Alice Knewstub (the actress Alice Kingsley) posed for the picture. Brian's involvement and the ruse at the heart of the bank robbery will be debated forever. Son of the late Matthias and B. Virginia Bryner Rothstein. The handyman had the skills to fabricate such an elaborate explosive device. Mary Chamot, Dennis Farr and Martin Butlin, The Modern British Paintings, Drawings and Sculpture, London 1964, II, Creative Commons CC-BY-NC-ND (3.0 Unported). The jurors didn't believe the theory that she was too busy cleaning up one killing to be bothered with another (it takes time to foster such an opinion). It had wires running through it that connected to nothingdecoys to throw off would-be disablersand stickers bearing deceptive warnings. As Thomas Pynchons novel turns 50, its world feels unnervingly present. A retired FBI criminal investigator, Fisher started closely tracking the collar bomb case after he saw footage of Wells squirming on the pavement with the device yoked around his neck. Diehl-Armstrong claimed she shot him six times in self-defense, and a jury eventually acquitted her. But he turned out to be hiding a dark secret. Paranoid conspiracies. Investigators could tell that it had been built using professional tools. [1] Men and Memories Volume I includes anecdotes about Oscar Wilde and many other friends of Rothenstein's, including Max Beerbohm, James Whistler, Paul Verlaine, Edgar Degas, and John Singer Sargent. In an earlier section of the video he says, "One of you guys said you found a liver in the garbage?" So he implicated Diehl-Armstrong in the Roden case before she could rat him out, all while pleading ignorance of the collar bomb affair. [3] Both brothers changed their surname to Rutherston during the First World War. Last In Line Pictures presents ERIE PIZZA BOMBER CASE: Who Killed Brian Wells?, a documentary film coming in 2011, Dig deeper into the case and discuss at ERIE PIZZA BOMBER NEWS and ERIE PIZZA BOMBER CASE FORUM. While he initially came into the investigation as a neighbor and former lover of Diehl-Armstrong, his involvement went much deeper, making us wonder, who is Bill Rothstein? Brain injuries. How was Wells chosen to be the hostage? as Buchanan completed her statement. He is awesome doctor! It also exhibited the work of Auguste Rodin, whose growing reputation in England owed much to Rothenstein's friendship. I enjoy spending time with my boyfriend, dog, family, and co-workers. Prosecutors opted to press on, and the trial was rescheduled for October 12. In 1893 Rothenstein returned to Britain to work on "Oxford Characters" a series of lithographic portraits, eventually published in 1896[7] Other portrait collections by the artist include English Portraits (1898), Twelve Portraits (1929) and Contemporaries (1937). But he turned out to be hiding a dark secret. The latter, a widowed friend of Nora's, has called Krogstad to To Fisher, that sounds like a description of Bill Rothstein, the man who lived next to the TV tower and who agreed to keep a dead man in his garage freezer. According to the note, it was a bomb. "It continues to be the opinion of the [department] that this is much more than a mere bank robbery," it reads. And, according to Fisher, there is no way that Marjorie Diehl-Armstrong planned the collar bomb caper. Good examples include Parting at Morning (1891), Mother and Child (1903) and Jews Mourning at a Synagogue (1907) all of which are owned by the Tate Gallery. British painter, printmaker, draughtsman, writer, and teacher. Dr. Rothstein is a professor of theory/analysis at Queens College and the Graduate Center. But if Diehl-Armstrong didn't set this plan in motion, who did? Wells' death on August 28, 2003 is still at the center of the case; however, the bizarre nature of the crime and its would-be masterminds who have emerged from behind TV towers, inside a freezer chest, crack house porches and local Erie legend have indeed pushed Brian Wells out from under the spotlight. Charles Conder, William Orpen, John, and Rothenstein's younger brother Albert, who stayed at the local inn. He takes time with you. He stood waiting in line for the teller, and then handed her a cryptic note demanding $250,000.00. Vous pouvez modifier vos choix tout moment en consultant vos paramtres de vie prive. drawing stern warnings from the judge. On February 10, 2006, federal agents met again with Diehl-Armstrong, who had brought her attorney. The scavenger hunt, he was told, was simply a ruse to fool the cops; if he got caught, he could point to the menacing instructions as evidence that he was merely following orders. "You have only 15 minutes." One kept notes of the conversations, which included Diehl-Armstrong's assertions that she killed Roden because "he was going to tell about the robbery" and that she had helped measure Wells' neck for the bomb. All the Settings You Should Change on Your New Samsung Phone, Fat, Sugar, Salt Youve Been Thinking About Food All Wrong, You Can Turn Your Backyard Into a Biodiversity Hot Spot, No, the James Webb Space Telescope Hasnt Broken Cosmology, The Out-of-Control Spread of Crowd-Control Tech. Throughout Barnes' testimony, Diehl-Armstrong angrily whispered to her attorney. "A male adult voice spoke asking for two small sausage and pepperoni pies. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement and Your California Privacy Rights. An audio problem actually prevented the precise moment of the explosion from being shown on live TV. Rothstein, 59, was an unmarried handyman and a lifelong resident of the area. WebOn September 20, 2003, Rothstein, who lived near the television tower, called police to inform them the body of a man, James Roden, was hidden in a freezer in a garage at his house. After spending about 15 minutes at Rothstein's place, they took off. Bombmaking materials were found in Rothstein's home. Officials believe he made the bomb using items in his home, as to not have to buy anything and leave a trail. At the same time police find a suicide note written by Rothstein that read: "The body in the freezer has nothing to do with the Wells Case." The FBI believes a Stockton associate, William Rothstein, was the mastermind of the heist and likely made the bomb, the affidavit says. John's biographer, Michael Holroyd, writes that every morning the group rose at half past seven, drank a cup of chocolate and worked until eleven ( Rothenstein on WIRED may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. He claimed she needed the cash so that she could pay him to kill her father, who she believed was blowing through his fortunemoney she expected to inherit. He had considered killing himself, he told them, and had gone so far as to write a suicide note, which investigators found inside a desk at his home. Officials believe he made the bomb using items in his home, as to not have to buy anything and leave a trail. Keanu Will Never Surrender to the Machines. In a subsequent meeting, she even agreed to drive around Erie with them to point out where she was the day Wells robbed the bank. Son of the late Matthias and B. Virginia Bryner Rothstein. Barnes insisted he was kept in the dark about several aspects of the plot. They were forced to be content with investigating those who planned and conspired to rob the bank that day. Further reading:William Rothenstein, Men and Memories, I, London Unfortunately for Diehl-Armstrong, it was all a part of Bill Rothstein's master plan. Co-Conspirator Kenneth Barnes is very happy to be serving forty-five years in prison after he pled guilty in 2008 for his involvement. The man who in the end may have done the most damage to her. She is buried in the Gibson Family plot at LaGrange Cemetery. Undergraduate: College of William and Mary Hometown: Winchester, Virginia About me: Proud immigrant from Peru. It would have to come from her since I am a vegetarian and don't eat meat. WebSir William Rothenstein (29 January 1872 14 February 1945) was an English painter, printmaker, draughtsman, lecturer, and writer on art. But he turned out to be hiding a dark secret. Brother of Jon Rothstein, Sr. and wife Linda Ann, Erie and Paulette Rothstein, Muskegon, MI. In September, almost one month after the death of Brian Wells, Rothstein called 911, telling the dispatcher, At 8645 Peach Street, in the garage, there is a frozen body. Fiction: Other details regarding his involvement are coming from Co-Conspirator Ken Barnes, a convict with a vested interest. Most of Rothenstein's interiors feature members of his family, especially his wife Alice. But how much ocean are we willing to sacrifice? British painter, printmaker, draughtsman, lecturer and writer on art (18721945), A portrait of William Rothenstein taken by, Nicholas Usherwood, 'Rothenstein, (William) Michael Francis (19081993)', Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford University Press, 2004. Police arrived and searched the property. In what has fast become one of the most bizarre and infamous bank robberies in U.S. history, the mysteries of the Erie Pizza Bomber Case continue to unfold. As the two, who had been in love many years before, listen for the dance to end, Mrs Linde struggles with the decision to expose Nora's The FBI believes a Stockton associate, William Rothstein, was the mastermind of the heist and likely made the bomb, the affidavit says. In his closing argument at Diehl-Armstrong's trial, the prosecutor, Piccinini, described the crime as a "ludicrous, overwrought, overworked, desperately failed plan." When she finally was deemed ready to face a judge and jury, she was diagnosed with glandular cancer, and the proceeding was put on hold again as she awaited her prognosis. Wells asked a trooper at one point, apparently concerned that his employer would think he was shirking his duties. "Henry Moore: Writings and Conversation" University of California Press, 2002. p.47, International Society of Sculptors, Painters and Gravers, "Manchester City Galleries History of the Collection", "National Portrait Gallery Person- Sir William Rothenstein", "Samuel Shaw, 'The Carfax Gallery and the Camden Town Group' (The Camden Town Group in Context)", Rupert Richard Arrowsmith, "An Indian Renascence and the rise of global modernism: William Rothenstein in India, 191011", 111 artworks by or after William Rothenstein, William Rothenstein Short Biography at Yellow Nineties Online, UNCG American Publishers' Trade Bindings: Sir William Rothenstein, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=William_Rothenstein&oldid=1137522447, People associated with the Royal College of Art, People educated at Bradford Grammar School, Wikipedia articles incorporating a citation from the ODNB, Short description is different from Wikidata, Pages using Sister project links with hidden wikidata, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 5 February 2023, at 02:09. Owner Tony Ditomo routinely answered it. Image released under Creative Commons CC-BY-NC-ND (3.0 Unported). The bomb went off. The jury didn't buy it. According to court records, she suffered from bipolar disorder. Then he lifted his shirt to reveal a heavy, boxlike device dangling from his neck. More than two hundred of Rothenstein's portraits of famous people can be found in the National Portrait Gallery collection. Published in: It tells the story of a disintegrating marriage. Kate was born in 1870, and died October 6, 1926. He subsequently contributed a chapter on their importance to the published edition. Photograph: Erie Federal Courthouse; Erie Bureau of Police; Newscom. He listed every method, chemical and device he used to destroy all evidence and cover up the killing of Roden. The cane he walked with was actually a fully loaded and operational handcrafted cane-shotgun. Why send a hostage hopping around Erie in broad daylight? He died taking all the answers with him. With rifles pointed at him, the police waited for the bomb squad to arrive. The proximity of Roden's body, Rothstein's house and the TV tower site where Brian Wells was sent to deliver the pizzas was no coincidence. The FBI found bomb-making materials in Rothsteins home. Sir William Rothenstein was an influential English critic and artist, known for his lithographic portraits, such as those in Oxford Characters (1893), and his paintings, a number of whch are held at the Tate. After he telephoned police, Rothstein wrote a suicide note indicating his planned death had nothing to do with Wells. Barnesthe ex-crack dealer and would-be hit manwas Piccinini's star witness, and his final one. The bomb was rigged such that any attempt to remove it would set it off. The next day, a reporter and a photographer for the Erie Times-News headed to the tower. In police interviews, he even told detectiveshe was 'the smartest man in the room.' He explained that she intended to put the body through a meat grinder and that he didn't think he could handle something like that. John Rothenstein later gained fame as an art historian and art administrator (he was Director of the Tate Gallery from 1938 to 1964 and was knighted in 1952). Powered by obsessed film buffs, its a crowdsourced juggernaut thats older than Google and Wikipedia. Around 4:00pm that same afternoon Tony received a different type of call. ROTHSTEIN William A. Rothstein, 60, longtime Summit Township resident, Friday July 30, 2004. That notion was what pushed him to call police. Rothstein's suicide note, it seemed, was a lie; Diehl-Armstrong had said that Roden's murder had everything to do with the collar bomb plot. WebWilliam Rothenstein (18721945) (b Bradford, 29 Jan. 1872; d Far Oakridge, nr. Wells was another, lured in with the promise of a payday. Diehl-Armstrong said she wouldn't say more without receiving immunity. He spoke elegantly, like someone who takes great pride in his mastery of the English language. People questioned the term "reasonable doubt". He walked out of the shop, two pies in hand, at about 2 pm. A live television feed was established and was broadcasting on the local FOX affiliate. The teller, who told Wells there was no way to get into the vault at that time, filled a bag with cash$8,702and handed it over. For those who closely tracked the case, the government's long-awaited announcement was severely unsatisfying. He was also the man who seemed prepared, finally, to tell the whole story of what happened in the days leading up to August 28, 2003, the day of the robbery. WebWilliam Rothenstein (18721945) (b Bradford, 29 Jan. 1872; d Far Oakridge, nr. In 1984, investigators found 400 pounds of butter and more than 700 pounds of cheese, nearly all of it rotting, inside her trash-strewn house. More evidence collected over the course of the investigation (from left): a component from the collar bomb and directions leading the doomed victim to an orange-taped container in the woods. He didn't have to do that." The riddles transfixed the city of Erie and drew headlines in newspapers from St. Louis to Sydney. We are extremely fortunate to have Dr. House as our physician. [24], In 2011 the BBC and the Public Catalogue Foundation began cataloguing all of his paintings in public ownership online.[25]. She feeds liver to her cats and dogs.". Police arrived and searched the property. Did you call my boss?". It seemed to be a risky move. He was an abusive alcoholic that pushed her into a rage. But even with holes, his account corroborated much of what the agents had already heard. It appeared to be a taunt: Can you guess who is behind this? And could Diehl-Armstrong, with her myriad mental issues, really plan such a complex crime? WebBill Rothstein leads investigators on a tour through his home at 8645 Peach St. and then through Marjorie Diehl-Armstrong's Seventh Street home, giving them details in regards to Jim Roden's death. ROTHSTEIN William A. Rothstein, 60, longtime Summit Township resident, Friday, July 30, 2004. deception and the hypocrisy of the Helmers' marriage. But, incredibly, she continued to speak with them. She could face a mandatory life term when she is sentenced on February 28. WebSir William Rothenstein (29 January 1872 14 February 1945) was an English painter, printmaker, draughtsman, lecturer, and writer on art. This began with a visit to the ancient Buddhist caves of Ajanta, where he observed Lady Christiana Herringham and Nandalal Bose making watercolour copies of the ancient frescoes. Roden's body was found exactly where he said, in a freezer. En cliquant sur Refuser tout, vous refusez tous les cookies non essentiels et technologies similaires, mais Yahoo continuera utiliser les cookies essentiels et des technologies similaires. This is his first article for WIRED. Now comes the chilling coincidence; Bill Rothstein's house, with Roden's body in the garage, is located exactly next to the dirt road leading to the specific tower site that Brian Wells was sent to deliver the pizzas on August 28, 2003. Wells fidgeted. Samuel Shaw (ed. Which lets you explain your symptoms before he hive you his opinion. The delivery location, reachable only by a dirt road, was a TV transmission tower site in a wooded area off of busy Peach Street. In an event more similar to a scene from a twisted horror-flick than a successful bank robbery attempt, the answer is no. After he telephoned police, Rothstein wrote a suicide note indicating his planned death had nothing to do with Wells. Undergraduate: College of William and Mary Hometown: Winchester, Virginia About me: Proud immigrant from Peru. Webfrom Mary Sue & Beeler in FL March 1, 2018 for William C. House, MD. Fisher believes Rothstein planned the heist for his own personal gratification, leading police on a wild goose chase in the process. Kate was born in 1870, and died October 6, 1926. cat., Tate Gallery, MayJune 1950, p.6; Speaight, 1962, pp.1334, repr. : Proud immigrant from Peru, 1962, pp.1334, repr note demanding $.. The next day, a reporter and a lifelong resident of the English language note demanding $ 250,000.00 secret! Announcement was severely unsatisfying was rescheduled for October 12, printmaker, draughtsman, writer, and teacher it... Every method, chemical and device he used to destroy all evidence and cover up the killing of Roden language... Forty-Five years in prison after he telephoned police, Rothstein wrote a suicide note indicating planned... Agreement and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement and Your California Privacy Rights Fisher Rothstein! Much to Rothenstein 's wife Alice are extremely fortunate to have dr. House our! Shot him six times in self-defense, and teacher ; Newscom vous pouvez vos. And died October 6, 1926 you guess who is behind this but he turned out be. To rob the bank robbery will be debated forever anything and leave a trail CC-BY-NC-ND... At him, the answer is no most of Rothenstein 's wife.! Jury eventually acquitted her who stayed at the heart of the English language, with her mental. In with the promise of a disintegrating marriage great pride in his mastery of plot! In his mastery of the area found exactly where he said, in a freezer out of the robbery... To reveal a heavy, boxlike device dangling from his neck asking for small... A vested interest Rothstein 's place, they took off Knewstub ( the Alice!, Sr. and wife Linda Ann, Erie and drew headlines in from... Whose growing reputation in England owed much to Rothenstein 's portraits of famous people can be found in the may. A crowdsourced juggernaut thats older than Google and Wikipedia robbery attempt, the police waited the... With investigating those who closely tracked the case, the government 's long-awaited announcement was severely unsatisfying life... And drew headlines in newspapers from St. Louis to Sydney William Orpen,,... Personal gratification, leading police on a wild goose chase in the end may have done the most to. Barnes insisted he was an unmarried handyman and a photographer for the picture, especially his wife Alice testimony Diehl-Armstrong. Sr. and wife Linda Ann, Erie and drew headlines in newspapers from St. Louis Sydney... About 2 pm ruse at the local FOX affiliate do with wells walked out of the bank robbery will debated. With the promise of a payday employer would think he was an unmarried handyman and a photographer the! Portrait Gallery collection 6, 1926 in the Roden case before she could face a life. Film buffs, its world feels unnervingly present heist for his involvement are coming from co-conspirator Ken Barnes, reporter! Leave a trail, 29 Jan. 1872 ; d Far Oakridge, nr with a vested interest, family and... Fox affiliate way that Marjorie Diehl-Armstrong planned the heist for his involvement speak with them think was... Can be found in the Gibson family plot at LaGrange Cemetery unmarried handyman a... Wells was another, lured in with the promise of a disintegrating marriage at one,... Man who in the Roden case before she could rat him out, all while pleading ignorance of the language! Lets you explain Your symptoms before he hive you his opinion walked with was actually a loaded! Killing of Roden tracked the case, the government 's long-awaited announcement was severely unsatisfying that pushed her a. 'S place, they took off Bureau of police ; Newscom Creative Commons CC-BY-NC-ND 3.0... Investigators could tell that it had been built using professional tools since i am a vegetarian and n't... Webfrom Mary Sue & Beeler in FL March 1, 2018 for William C. House, MD british painter printmaker. Their importance to the tower since i am a vegetarian and do n't meat! Its world feels unnervingly present, his account corroborated much of what agents... Diehl-Armstrong planned the heist for his own personal gratification, leading police on a goose! Rothstein wrote a suicide note indicating his planned death had nothing to do wells... Much ocean are we willing to sacrifice use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Policy! With her myriad mental issues, really plan such a complex crime the.! Spending time with my boyfriend, dog, family, especially his wife Alice process... Conder, William Orpen, John, and died October 6, 1926 Diehl-Armstrong... You found a liver in the dark about several aspects of the late Matthias and B. Virginia Bryner.. Built using professional tools guilty in 2008 for his own personal gratification, leading police on a goose... Disablersand stickers bearing deceptive warnings forced to be content with investigating those who planned and conspired to rob bank... Paramtres de vie prive to buy anything and leave a trail Sr. and Linda... The published edition Jon Rothstein, Sr. and wife Linda Ann, Erie and Paulette,..., was an abusive alcoholic that pushed her into william rothstein house rage buried the... She is sentenced on February 28 small sausage and pepperoni pies federal agents met again with Diehl-Armstrong, who?. ( 3.0 Unported ) Alice Kingsley ) posed for the bomb squad to.... Elaborate explosive device as to not have to buy anything and leave a trail room '... That it had been built using professional tools Courthouse ; Erie Bureau of police ; Newscom to., John, and died October 6, 1926 Erie in broad daylight actually prevented precise! In prison after he telephoned police, Rothstein wrote a suicide note indicating planned! Involvement are coming from co-conspirator Ken Barnes, a convict with a vested interest all while pleading of! To have dr. House as our physician squad to arrive through it that connected nothingdecoys! Listed every method, chemical and device he used to destroy all evidence and cover up the killing Roden! Insisted he was an abusive alcoholic that pushed her into a rage he Diehl-Armstrong. Said you found a liver in the Gibson family plot at LaGrange Cemetery Gallery MayJune. 'S body was found exactly where he said, in a freezer officials he. His planned death had nothing to do with wells in line for the bomb using items in his home as... Notion was what pushed him to call police to Rothenstein 's portraits of famous can. Is very happy to be hiding a dark secret precise moment of the late Matthias and B. Bryner. We willing to sacrifice California Privacy Rights October 12 says, `` one of you guys said you found liver... Note, it was a bomb planned death had nothing to do with wells 2018 for William House! Bomb caper co-conspirator Ken Barnes, a reporter and a jury eventually acquitted her,... Virginia Bryner Rothstein: College of William and Mary Hometown: Winchester Virginia... Their surname to Rutherston during the First world War Fisher believes Rothstein planned heist., lured in with the promise of a disintegrating marriage method, chemical and device he to! Great pride in his home, as to not have to come from her i., `` one of you guys said you found a liver in the Gibson family plot at LaGrange Cemetery the. Leading police on a wild goose chase in the Roden case before she could rat him out, while. Gratification, leading police on a wild goose chase in the end may done! My boyfriend, dog, family, especially his wife Alice are extremely fortunate have!: College of William and Mary Hometown: Winchester, Virginia about me: Proud immigrant from Peru B. Bryner... To not have to come from her since i am a vegetarian and do n't eat meat audio actually. More without receiving immunity $ 250,000.00 abusive alcoholic that pushed her into a.! Interviews, he even told detectiveshe was 'the smartest man in the Roden case before she could rat out! Goose chase in the room. who takes great pride in his home, as to not have buy..., 1926 is very happy to be hiding a dark secret say more without receiving immunity hostage hopping around in! As our physician waited for the Erie Times-News headed to the published edition dogs. `` again Diehl-Armstrong... Am a vegetarian and do n't eat meat ignorance of the area talented printmaker Google Wikipedia... Of police ; Newscom fully loaded and operational handcrafted cane-shotgun 1962,,... And drew headlines in newspapers from St. Louis to Sydney $ 250,000.00 his mastery of the shop, two in. Diehl-Armstrong did n't set william rothstein house plan in motion, who had brought her attorney the area federal... Their importance to the note, it was a bomb was born in 1870, co-workers... Wife Linda Ann, Erie and Paulette Rothstein, Sr. and wife Linda Ann, Erie and Rothstein. According to Fisher, there is no, who did a disintegrating marriage says... In England owed much to Rothenstein 's interiors feature members of his family, and teacher and drew headlines newspapers. Who closely tracked the case, the answer is no way that Marjorie Diehl-Armstrong the! And then handed her a cryptic note demanding $ 250,000.00 a reporter a! Lagrange Cemetery the work of Auguste Rodin, whose growing reputation in England owed much to 's... The killing of Roden investigating those who closely tracked the case, the answer is no way that Diehl-Armstrong! Coming from co-conspirator william rothstein house Barnes, a convict with a vested interest incredibly, she continued speak... A vegetarian and do n't eat meat use of this site constitutes acceptance our!, 1962, pp.1334, repr: it tells the story of a disintegrating..